As an avid user of Tweetdeck I was pretty sure I couldn’t be converted. But when Seesmic Look came along today I did stop and wonder…
I love the Seesmic Look (SL) interface and the design they have used however it just doesn’t do the job for me.
Using Tweetdeck I can operate at good speeds, not spend time waiting for ‘things’ to load and essentially using as a proper Twitter dashboard to keep me on top of going’s on.
I totally see how and why SL was created, it is beautiful and fluid, but it misses the vital point for users such as myself which is speed. The time lines pulse in and out, the Tweets float as if they are alive…did I mention the design was very fluid…?
On entering you’re dropped straight on to the Trends page to show what is going on across Twitter – this suggests you want to know this versus diving straight in to find out what is going on in your part of the Twitterverse (can’t believe I wrote that word…)

The navigation is very easy to use. Click, slide and the various menu’s drop in and out as you would expect of a tool of this calibre. The video timeline is useful (just like Google Waves) as it shows you how stuff has dropped in chronologically. You can also select just your Twitter lists to see who’s said what on that list alone – now that is a useful idea but again…it’s a bit too slow getting to the point!

The channels idea is pretty sweet and I can see a number of brands enjoying getting involved in this. Simple to immerse yourself in one of the preloaded ones and very simple to get around. Check out the Red Bull one and you can instantly get hold of all their Twitter users and see what they are saying – quite nice. Kinda like Interactive TV mini-sites but on a Twitter-powered app.

This is where it does get a little more interesting to me. Interests is a great way to navigate Twitter just like you would a Sunday paper. You find the section of the paper you like – Business, Sport, etc – and then you open/click it and voila – your interest is in front of you. Not too many interests are catered for so you have to have a general interest (much like the Sunday paper) however you can build your own list as an interest and simply view your personal interest that way.

So what do I thin overall and am I going to convert…hmmm…
The problem I have is that it is too beautiful for it’s own good. It’s so nice to use that it gets in the way of what you’re trying to achieve which is a quick fix of what is going on. If you had a good 30mins every hour to use SL it would be a marvellous experience. However I don’t and therefore speed is important to me far over and above beauty.
But, in defence of SL they do say it is ‘designed with the casual user in mind’ so I guess I may not be that person.
So that’s that for moment. I am going to persevere for a few days (if I can afford that much time!) and see what changes but for the meantime…
…I’m back to Tweetdeck to Tweet this blog post because it is much, much quicker…